I experienced high hopes for #4, predicated on their search picture on POF, but their dating headline is really bad past it, even if they aren’t a BBW that I can’t imagine anyone reading.

Although it is crucial that you be upfront with individuals in your profile, there’s a significant difference between being a jerk.

Composing the same in principle as “no fat chicks” at the top of your profile lands you squarely within the jerk category and can frighten down perhaps the skinniest of ladies.

The remainder of #4’s profile is in fact so good. He takes it in a funny direction that appears to match their personality, therefore it does not feel forced. This could be an approach that is good you're looking to casually date. It's a profile that provides a vibe about yourself but does not provide any information that is real individuals to locate one thing much more serious would like to understand. Along with that stated, there are a few things I’d do...